This 1970s Recipe for Tom and Jerry Mix Was Made for a Holiday Punch Bowl

August 22, 2026
Updated: November 5, 2026

This recipe for Tom and Jerry mix is a 1970s community cookbook batter made from separated eggs, butter, powdered sugar, and warm baking spices like nutmeg, mace, cloves, and allspice. The whipped egg white method keeps this tom and jerry batter recipe light.

One 1970s community cookbook recipe called for twelve eggs and three pounds of sugar, enough batter to keep an entire holiday party running past midnight.

This nostalgic Tom and Jerry mix solves the one thing most holiday drink recipes get wrong: instead of remixing a fresh round every time someone wants a warm cocktail, you make one batch and serve it mug by mug all season long. 

I first found this tom and jerry recipe in a cookbook that belonged to my great-aunt Hazel (Mamaw's sister), and the ratio of eggs to sugar told me immediately this batter meant business. I've made it in small batches and full punch bowl size, and the version below keeps the texture the original cook was clearly after: light, not gloopy, with just enough spice to taste like Christmas.

This version keeps the original 1970s ratios intact and you'll get a batter with the texture of soft frosting, spiced enough to stand up to a full jigger ðŸ›’ of dark rum or brandy. 

If this Tom and Jerry batter has you in a nostalgic mood, don't stop here. Try the 1906 Broome Family Brandy Eggnog Recipe next, a cold, creamy counterpart from the same golden era of handwritten family recipe cards, built on the same trick of separating eggs for a lighter, richer texture.

Print
clockclock iconcutlerycutlery iconflagflag iconfolderfolder iconinstagraminstagram iconpinterestpinterest iconfacebookfacebook iconprintprint iconsquaressquares iconheartheart iconheart solidheart solid icon
Recipe for tom and jerry mix in a glass mug, topped with whipped cream and nutmeg

Recipe for Tom and Jerry Mix

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

A recipe for tom and jerry mix like the one here comes from a 1970s cookbook, built on the classic egg batter method Jerry Thomas popularized in his 1862 bartending guide. Whipped egg whites, creamed butter, and four warm spices combine into a rich batter that turns hot water or hot milk into an instant Tom and Jerry cocktail. One batch makes enough Tom and Jerry batter for an entire holiday punch bowl party.

  • Total Time: 30 minutes
  • Yield: 60 servings 1x

Email me this recipe

Enter your email and we’ll send the recipe right to you.

Ingredients

Units Scale
  • 12 large eggs, separated
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 4 sticks butter, room temperature
  • 11 cups powdered sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon rum or brandy flavoring
  • 1 teaspoon mace
  • 1 teaspoon nutmeg
  • 1 teaspoon cloves
  • 1 teaspoon allspice
  • Rum or brandy, for serving
  • Boiling water or hot milk, for serving
  • Extra nutmeg, for garnish

Instructions

  1. Prep your station first: Set out two large mixing bowls and let the butter come fully to room temperature before you start. Separate all 12 eggs, whites in one bowl and yolks in another.
  2. Whip the egg whites to stiff peaks: Beat the egg whites with the salt until they hold stiff peaks, about 4 to 5 minutes. Set the bowl aside; you’ll fold these in last.
  3. Cream the butter and sugar: In a separate bowl, cream the butter and powdered sugar together until the mixture turns light and slightly crumbly, about 2 minutes on medium speed.
  4. Add the yolks and flavorings: Beat the egg yolks separately until light, then mix them into the butter and sugar with the vanilla extract and rum or brandy flavoring. Beat until fully combined.
  5. Fold in the spices and egg whites: Add the mace, nutmeg, cloves, and allspice, then gently fold in the stiff egg whites just until no streaks remain. Overmixing here will deflate your batter and flatten your froth.
  6. Store the batter: Transfer to an airtight container. The batter keeps in the refrigerator about 2 days.
  7. Serve one Tom and Jerry: Pour a jigger of rum or brandy into a warmed mug, add a heaping tablespoon of batter, then fill with boiling water or hot milk. Stir well and finish with a dash of nutmeg on top.

Notes

Egg Safety Note

The batter uses raw eggs, the way the 1970s original did. The FDA says fresh eggs, even clean ones with uncracked shells, may contain Salmonella, and it recommends pasteurized eggs or pasteurized egg products for any recipe where the eggs stay raw or undercooked. Rum and brandy won’t change that. The alcohol is there for flavor, not food safety.

Children, older adults, pregnant women, and people with weakened immune systems face the greatest risk of serious illness. If any of them are at your table, use pasteurized eggs or skip the batter.

Pasteurized egg whites from a carton are easy to find, though they whip slower.

Pin This Recipe For Tom and Jerry Mix

Recipe for tom and jerry mix in a glass mug, topped with whipped cream and nutmeg

Back in the Day: Tom and Jerry From a Boston Courtroom to a 1970s Cookbook

Fall River Monitor Mar 24 1827 - Police report of a 13 year old boy drunk on Tom and Jerry.

Fall River Monitor March 24, 1827

On March 24, 1827, the Fall River Monitor reprinted a Boston police court item that reads like a very bad week. A boy of about thirteen was tried for stealing a watch and acquitted.

Along the way, it came out that the man who brought the charge had sold him a drink under the name "Tom and Jerry," a composition of saleratus, eggs, sugar, nutmeg, ginger, allspice and rum. A female witness said the boy seemed perfectly deranged when the watch went missing, probably from the "hell-broth" he'd been drinking.

The paper didn't stop to explain the name, so readers likely knew it already. Saleratus was an early baking soda, so the 1827 drink wasn't the batter on the recipe card. Here's how it got from that courtroom to a 1970s punch bowl.

Recipe for tom and jerry mix from 1862 - Bar-Tender's Guide, or How to Mix Drinks: The Bon-Vivant's Companion

Recipe for tom and jerry mix from 1862 - Bar-Tender's Guide, or How to Mix Drinks: The Bon-Vivant's Companion

1862: Jerry Thomas Writes It Down

The first detailed recipe in print came in 1862, when "Professor" Jerry Thomas, a famous American bartender working in New York City, included it in his "Bar-Tender's Guide, or How to Mix Drinks: The Bon-Vivant's Companion."

His original instructions called for beating the whites of the eggs to a stiff froth and the yolks until thin, then folding both together with Jamaican rum and spice until the mixture reached "the consistence of a light batter," a description this modern jerry batter recipe still follows closely.

Mid-1900s: The Punch Bowl Sets Come Out

By the mid-twentieth century, the drink had become a fixture of the Christmas season across the United States, especially in the upper Midwest, where families kept dedicated Tom and Jerry punch bowl sets on hand every December.

Companies like Hazel-Atlas produced milk glass punch bowl sets with festive holiday designs and gold or colored lettering, meant to sit on the table at family gatherings all December long, not just for one round of drinks.

Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale Tom and Jerry Tent Card

Tom and Jerry tent card from Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale, Minneapolis MN

Minneapolis restaurants leaned into the tradition too. Charlie's Cafe Exceptionale, a landmark downtown Minneapolis restaurant, put out table tent cards each December advertising Tom and Jerry as "the traditional holiday drink," serving it to regulars right alongside the lutefisk dinners and famous potato salad the restaurant was better known for.

The tradition never fully disappeared either; pre-made Tom and Jerry batter is still sold in supermarkets today across Wisconsin, Minnesota, the Dakotas, and Montana every holiday season.

1970s: The Community Cookbook Version

The recipe above comes from a 1970s community cookbook, the kind where readers sent in their own recipes. Great-aunt Hazel's copy kept the separate whites and yolks from the 1862 version, and added butter and powdered sugar. Twelve eggs make enough for a whole party, and the batter ladles into mugs straight from the bowl.

Why This Recipe for Tom and Jerry Mix Still Works Today

Whipping Egg Whites Separately Traps More Air

Beating the egg whites on their own, away from the fat in the yolks, is what gives this batter its lift. Fat coats the proteins in egg whites and keeps them from unfolding and bonding into a stable foam, so even a trace of yolk in the wrong bowl will flatten your peaks before they start.

Powdered Sugar Dissolves Into Butter Without Grit

Powdered sugar's fine texture and small amount of cornstarch let it dissolve into softened butter almost immediately, instead of leaving the gritty pockets granulated sugar can leave behind. That's the difference between a smooth, frosting-like base and a batter that tastes sandy in the mug.

Folding Keeps the Batter From Deflating

Folding the whipped egg whites in with a wide spatula, rather than stirring or beating them, disturbs the air bubbles as little as possible. Stirring briskly pops those bubbles outright, which is why a batter that looked airy in the bowl can turn flat and heavy the second you get impatient with it.

Warm Spices Bloom in Hot Liquid

Nutmeg, clove, and allspice hold onto their aromatic oils tightly at room temperature, and heat is what coaxes those oils loose. That's why the spiced batter tastes mild on its own but turns fragrant and warm the moment boiling water or hot milk hits the mug.

How to Make the Perfect Recipe for Tom and Jerry Mix

Perfecting this recipe for Tom and Jerry mix comes down to five small technique details that separate a light, frothy drink from a flat, heavy one.

Beat the Whites Until They Hold a Peak, Not a Puddle

Stop the mixer and lift the beater straight up; if the egg whites hold a stiff, pointed peak without folding over, you're done. Under-beaten whites collapse into the batter and leave you with a flat, heavy drink instead of a frothy one.

Use Room-Temperature Butter or the Sugar Won't Cream Evenly

Cold butter resists the sugar and leaves gritty pockets in your finished batter instead of a smooth, crumbly texture. Set the butter out at least an hour before you start mixing, longer if your kitchen runs cool.

Fold, Don't Stir, When You Add the Egg Whites

Stirring briskly deflates all the air you just worked to whip into the whites, so use a wide spatula and gentle folding strokes instead. You're aiming for a batter with the consistency of a light batter, not a dense paste.

Warm the Mug Before You Pour

A cold mug pulls heat straight out of your hot water or hot milk, leaving a lukewarm drink within minutes. Run the mug under hot tap water for thirty seconds and dry it before you add the batter, or warm a whole set at once by leaving mugs in the dishwasher through a heated dry cycle, or by setting them on a baking sheet in a 170°F oven for eight to ten minutes.

If you're using a genuine vintage milk glass set, skip the dishwasher and oven methods and stick with the hot tap water rinse instead, since repeated heat cycles can cause older glass to crack.

Keep a Kettle of Hot Water Ready for a Crowd

If you're serving individual drinks for family gatherings or a full holiday party, keep a kettle 🛒 at a steady simmer on the stove rather than microwaving one mug at a time. It keeps the line moving and every mug at the same, ideal temperature.

Recipe Variations, Serving Ideas, & Storage

  • Recipe Variations

  • Serving Ideas

  • Make Ahead & Storage 

Recipe Variations

  • Make it with hot milk: Swap the boiling water for hot milk or heavy cream for a richer, creamier drink closer to a spiked egg nog.
  • Try brandy only: Swap the rum or brandy flavoring and the serving-time pour for brandy alone for a slightly warmer, less sweet finish closer to Jerry Thomas's original 1862 version.
  • Try Jamaican rum: Use Jamaican rum instead of brandy in each mug for a slightly funkier, more molasses-forward finish that pairs well with the warm spices in the batter.
  • Add a scoop of ice cream: Drop a small scoop of vanilla ice cream into the mug before pouring in the hot liquid for a dessert-style, extra creamy drink.
  • Boost the spice: Add an extra half teaspoon each of nutmeg and cloves if your family prefers a stronger, more pronounced Christmas spice flavor in every mug.

Tools & Ingredients Worth Having For This Recipe

We don’t run an ad network here. Instead, we quietly use Amazon links for tools that we use in our own kitchen and make sense for the recipes we share. If you choose to shop through those links, you help keep these vintage recipes alive and off the endangered list, at no extra cost to you.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does Tom and Jerry batter last in the fridge or freezer?

Tom and Jerry batter keeps in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 days.

Can I make Tom and Jerry mix without alcohol?

A tom and jerry mix recipe works fine without alcohol; simply fill the mug with hot milk or hot water and skip the rum or brandy entirely. 

What's the difference between a Tom and Jerry and egg nog?

Eggnog is a single mixed drink you pour and serve as is, like this 1906 Broome family brandy eggnog recipe, while Tom and Jerry mix is a thick batter you spoon into a mug and finish with hot water, hot milk, rum, or brandy. Tom and Jerry also leans more on warm baking spices like mace and allspice, giving it a flavor closer to a warm sugar cookie than plain eggnog.

Can I serve Tom and Jerry mix in a punch bowl for a crowd?

Serving Tom and Jerry mix from a punch bowl is actually the traditional method, dating back to bartender Jerry Thomas's own 1862 recipe, which called for mixing the full batch in a bowl before ladling it into individual mugs. Set the batter out with a kettle of hot water and let guests build their own mugs.

What's the best way to warm the mugs before serving?

Warming the mugs matters more than most people expect, since a cold ceramic mug pulls heat out of the drink within a minute or two. Run each mug under hot tap water for about thirty seconds and dry it thoroughly before adding the batter and hot liquid.

Bring the Punch Bowl Tradition Back to Your Table

A recipe that once lived quietly inside a 1970s cookbook now has a real shot at becoming your own family's holiday tradition, mug by warm mug. Set the batter out at your next gathering and watch how fast it disappears from the bowl.

If you try this recipe for Tom and Jerry mix, leave a star rating and let us know how your holiday party went!

Thanks for visiting Recipe Rewind!

About the Author

Melissa Sullivan

Melissa is the creator of Recipe Rewind. Self-taught since age seven, she's spent more than 30 years cooking with vintage recipes. Extensive travel broadened her palate, and raising four children taught her how to make from-scratch cooking work on a real schedule and budget. She now cooks in a household spanning five generations, from Silent Generation to Gen Z, so every recipe gets tested against people who remember the original and people who've never seen it before. She researches primary sources, including old cookbooks, church booklets, and period advertisements, before adapting a recipe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>