Eggnog French Toast With Brioche Is the Holiday Breakfast Tradition Worth Starting

October 7, 2026

Author: Melissa Sullivan

This page was updated on 11/10/2026

Eggnog French toast is a holiday season breakfast made by soaking thick brioche slices in a custard of eggs, prepared eggnog, vanilla, and salt, then frying them in butter until golden brown. Brioche's butter-rich crumb stays tender inside while the eggnog's sugar and nutmeg build a caramelized crust.

The 1906 Broome Family ruled Baltimore's Christmas parties with a punchbowl of eggnog, and I'm fairly sure nobody thought to fry the leftovers.

Let's be honest: eggnog is almost French toast batter already! It's got the cream, sugar, and nutmeg built right in, so all you need to add are a few more eggs, vanilla, and a pinch of salt.

No pressure to try a homemade eggnog recipe, though it really isn't difficult. A carton from the store works just as well for eggnog French toast. 

Thin bread is the real risk, since thinner slices can end up soggy in the middle, but thick, hand sliced brioche solves that issue.

Don't forget the whipped cream for a sweet topping! I even have different versions for you: Vanilla, almond, or brandy.

How to make whipped cream: close-up of fluffy peaks on electric mixer beaters
Brandied spiced whipped cream topped with cocoa dust
Print
clockclock iconcutlerycutlery iconflagflag iconfolderfolder iconinstagraminstagram iconpinterestpinterest iconfacebookfacebook iconprintprint iconsquaressquares iconheartheart iconheart solidheart solid icon
Eggnog French Toast made with sliced Brioche on a white platter

Eggnog French Toast Recipe

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

Eggnog French toast is a holiday breakfast built on thick brioche, a custard of eggs and prepared eggnog, and a butter-fried crust. The eggnog supplies the cream, sugar, and nutmeg, so the egg mixture needs only vanilla and salt. The result is a custardy center, a golden brown exterior, and a kitchen that smells like the holidays.

  • Total Time: 30 minutes
  • Yield: 6 servings 1x

Email me this recipe

Enter your email and we’ll send the recipe right to you.

Ingredients

Units Scale
  • 12 slices brioche, about 1 inch thick
  • 4 large eggs
  • 2 cups prepared eggnog
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • Pinch of salt
  • 1 stick of butter, divided

Instructions

  1. Slice the brioche: If you’re starting with a whole loaf, cut it into 12 slices about 1 inch thick. Pre-sliced brioche can go straight to the next step.
    Brioche sliced thick
  2. Mix the custard: Beat the eggs with the eggnog, vanilla extract, and salt in a shallow dish until no streaks of egg remain. Shake the carton first, since eggnog settles.
  3. Dip, don’t soak: Dip each slice into the mixture, turning to coat both sides. Let the extra drip back into the dish so the center doesn’t turn soggy.
    Thick sliced bread dipped in eggnog french toast batter.
  4. Fry in batches: Melt 2 tablespoons of the butter on a stovetop griddle or in a large skillet over medium heat. Add 2 or 3 slices and fry until golden brown on both sides. Repeat with the remaining bread and butter, using 2 tablespoons per batch.
    Frying brioche French toast on a stovetop griddle
  5. Serve right away: Stack two slices per plate and top with powdered sugar, warm maple syrup, hot stewed apples, fresh fruit, or brandy whipped cream.
    Brioche eggnog french toast topped with powdered sugar, whipped cream, and fresh strawberries.

 

Back in 1660, French Toast Was Soaked in Wine

Recipe for French Toasts in Robert May's The Accomplisht Cook, published in London in 1660
Recipe for A Sack Posset, Leeds University Library Cookery Collection

Recipe for A Sack Posset, Leeds University Library Cookery Collection

An English Cookbook Gave French Toast Its Name

The term French toast appears in Robert May's The Accomplisht Cook, published in London in 1660, according to the Oxford English Dictionary citation quoted by lexicographer Grant Barrett and Wordorigins.org.

May's recipe called for thick slices of French bread, toasted on a gridiron and served steeped in wine, with sugar and orange juice, as the 1660 edition at the University of Michigan Library shows. 

Eggnog Was Already a Status Drink in the 1600s

By the seventeenth century, the aristocracy drank eggnog with sherry as a sign of wealth, according to historian Anne Rothfeld in the National Library of Medicine's Circulating Now, published December 22, 2022.

One recipe she cites, My Lord of Carlisle's Sack-Posset, called for eighteen egg yolks, eight egg whites, and a pint of sherry!

Meanwhile, May's readers were steeping toast in wine, and as far as I can tell, nobody thought to combine the two. Your holiday table gets to fix that oversight.

What Makes Eggnog French Toast Work Every Time?

Brioche's Crumb Holds the Custard

Brioche holds eggnog custard because eggs and butter enrich its crumb, so the slice stays tender inside instead of collapsing. Plain sandwich bread soaks through fast and slumps in the pan. Thick brioche slices drink up the custard and still stand tall, with a custardy center and a crust that crisps in the butter.

Eggnog Already Contains the Custard Basics

Eggnog replaces the milk, cream, and sugar in a classic French toast custard because it already combines dairy, eggs, sugar, and nutmeg. Extra eggs thicken the egg mixture so it clings to the bread slices instead of running off. Skip added sugar since the eggnog already has plenty.

Salt and Vanilla Sharpen the Eggnog Flavor

A pinch of salt and a teaspoon of vanilla extract make the eggnog flavor taste rounder in the skillet. Salt balances sweetness, and vanilla adds aroma heat can otherwise mute. Without them, the finished toast tastes sweet but flat.

Butter Browns the Surface Evenly

Butter browns the slices because its milk solids and the sugars in eggnog caramelize on contact with hot metal. Eggnog's sugars brown fast, so keep the heat steady and watch the pan.

Which Bread Works Best for Eggnog French Toast?

IMO, thick-cut brioche works best for eggnog French toast, and Texas toast is the closest backup.

I've been making French toast forever, and my bread has changed with the decades. Back in the 80s, we used whatever white bread was in the bread box and never thought to use anything else. In the 90s I switched to Texas toast because the kids really like it, and in the early 2000s I used French bread for overnight, baked skier's French toast.

Brioche is definitely the best of the bunch. The finished texture is perfect: tender, custardy, and golden brown. The table below shows how each bread behaves in my skillet.

Bread

Texture After Frying

Best For

Brioche

Tender, custardy center with a golden crust

Holiday season breakfasts

Texas Toast

Soft and sturdy; soaks evenly

A budget-friendly swap

French Bread

Chewier; needs thick slices

A baked French toast casserole

Sandwich Bread

Soaks fast; can turn soggy

Last-minute breakfast when nothing else is in the pantry

Where to Buy Brioche for Eggnog French Toast

Brioche can be found at most grocery stores, though a bakery loaf gives the best texture, in my opinion. My local Kroger and Aldi both carry it, but I prefer buying from the bakery so I can slice it myself.

Flour House Bakery in downtown Tomball sells homemade brioche, and the loaf I picked up there made perfectly custardy eggnog French toast. If you happen to be in that area, check them out!

How to Make Perfect Eggnog French Toast

Rest Broome Family Eggnog Overnight

If you're using the Broome family eggnog, let it rest in the refrigerator overnight before making French toast. The recipe is very light and fluffy right after it's made, and from my own experience with it, the airy foam settles overnight, so the eggnog soaks into brioche instead of sitting on top. Halve the recipe when you're making it only for French toast. I use anything leftover in my morning coffee.

Cut Brioche ¾ to 1 Inch Thick

Slices cut ¾ to 1 inch thick hold eggnog custard best. Thinner slices turn limp and tear in the pan, and much thicker ones can brown before the center sets. If you're slicing your own loaf, aim for 1 inch. Pre-sliced brioche runs thinner, so dip it for just a few seconds per side.

Use Thick-Cut Brioche, Slightly Dry

Let the slices sit at room temperature for about 30 minutes before dipping. A drier crumb drinks more custard without falling apart. Very fresh, soft slices are the usual reason for mushy centers.

Shake the Eggnog Before Measuring

Shake or stir a store-bought carton, since cream and spice settle at the bottom. Skipping the shake gives you uneven eggnog flavor from the first slice to the last.

Dip Each Slice, Then Let It Drip

Turn each slice in a shallow dish, then hold it over the dish for a second. Brioche drinks fast, and an over-soaked slice goes limp and can scorch before the center sets.

Wipe the Skillet Between Batches

Wipe out burnt butter and sugar bits with a paper towel before each new batch.

Recipe Variations, Serving Ideas, & Storage

  • Recipe Variations

  • Serving Ideas

  • Make Ahead & Storage 

Recipe Variations

  • Add brandy flavor: Stir ½ teaspoon brandy extract into the egg mixture for a spiked taste without alcohol. It deepens the holiday twist and plays well with the nutmeg.
  • Spice it up: Add a pinch of ground nutmeg and cinnamon to the custard if your eggnog runs mild. A little extra spice brings back flavor store-bought cartons sometimes lose.
  • Bake it instead: Layer slices in a buttered baking dish, pour the custard over, and refrigerate overnight for a baked eggnog French toast casserole.

Tools & Ingredients Worth Having For This Recipe

We don’t run an ad network here. Instead, we quietly use Amazon links for tools that we actually use in our kitchen and make sense for the recipes we share. Shop through the links and you help keep these vintage recipes alive, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Lodge Pro-Grid Reversible Grill/Griddle
Eggnog French toast is rich with sugar and custard, so it browns fast and scorches if the heat is uneven.
Cast iron holds steady heat. That gives you an evenly golden crust and a set custard center instead of pale spots next to dark ones. The long surface fits several slices at once, so the whole family eats while it's still hot. Use the flat side for this recipe. Flip it to the ridged side for grilled sandwiches or vegetables another night.

Metal Spatula Set, Griddle Spatula and Scraper
Soaked bread is heavy and fragile. A thin, sturdy metal edge slides cleanly under a slice without tearing the crust. It also lets you flip each slice in one motion, which keeps the custard coating intact. The scraper edge lifts the caramelized sugar bits between batches. If they stay on the griddle, they burn and give the next round a bitter taste.

Sweejar Glass Pie Pan
A shallow, wide dish is the best way to soak bread for French toast. A slice lies flat and takes up custard evenly on both sides, with no cramped bowl and no soggy edges. Glass lets you see the custard level and check that nothing is sticking underneath. The two-pack lets you set up one dish for the soak and one for a second batch or a topping. These dishes also bake
pies, so they earn their cupboard space.

Deiss PRO Lemon Zester & Heavy Duty Grater
Its fine blades turn whole nutmeg into a soft, fluffy powder that blends smoothly into the custard. Coarse or uneven shavings leave gritty, sharp-tasting bits in the bread. The same tool zests citrus if you want a bright note against the eggnog. It also handles hard cheese, garlic, and chocolate, so it won't sit idle in a drawer.

iSpice Whole Nutmeg
Nutmeg is the signature flavor of eggnog, and it fades quickly once ground. Grating a whole nut just before cooking gives a warmer, more fragrant, more complex flavor than a jar of pre-ground spice. The difference is easy to taste in a recipe this simple. Whole nutmeg also keeps far longer in the pantry, so one bag will last through many holiday seasons.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you make eggnog French toast with store-bought eggnog?

Eggnog French toast works well with store-bought eggnog, including leftover eggnog from a carton that's within its use-by date and has stayed refrigerated. Shake the carton first, since cream and spice settle, and skip any carton that smells sour.

Should you rest Broome family eggnog before making French toast?

Broome family eggnog works better for French toast after resting in the refrigerator overnight. The recipe is very light and fluffy just after it's made, and a day in the fridge lets the foam settle so the brioche soaks up the eggnog. A halved batch covers one round of French toast.

What's the best bread for eggnog French toast?

Thick-cut brioche is the best bread for eggnog French toast because its egg-and-butter crumb stays tender after soaking. Texas toast is the closest backup. Thin sandwich bread tends to turn soggy.

Why is my eggnog French toast soggy in the middle?

Eggnog French toast turns soggy when the slices are over-soaked, cut too thin, or fried in a pan that isn't hot enough to set the custard. Dip each slice briefly, let it drip, and wait for the butter to foam before the bread goes in.

How do you know when eggnog French toast is done?

Eggnog French toast is done when both sides are golden brown and the center feels springy, not wet. Press gently with a spatula. A soft, squishy center needs another minute on lower heat.

Does eggnog French toast contain alcohol?

Eggnog French toast made with store-bought eggnog contains no added alcohol unless the carton is spiked, so check the label. Homemade eggnog follows its own recipe. Brandy extract gives the flavor without the alcohol.

Eggnog Deserves a Second Act at Breakfast

Eggnog doesn't have to wait for cocktail hour. Once the skillet's hot, a carton from the back of the fridge becomes the festive breakfast everyone remembers, and you'll be at the table before the syrup cools.

What food tradition runs your Christmas morning: sticky buns, a casserole, pumpkin waffles, or something your family would never let you change?

homemade pecan sticky buns on a pastel plate
Finished pumpkin waffle recipe makes a stack of 5 fluffy waffles, topped here with whipped cream

If eggnog French toast lands on your table this year, leave a star rating and a comment below so other home cooks can find it.

Thanks for visiting Recipe Rewind!

About the Author

Melissa Sullivan

Melissa is the creator of Recipe Rewind. Self-taught since age seven, she's spent more than 30 years cooking with vintage recipes. Extensive travel broadened her palate, and raising four children taught her how to make from-scratch cooking work on a real schedule and budget. She now cooks in a household spanning five generations, from Silent Generation to Gen Z, so every recipe gets tested against people who remember the original and people who've never seen it before. She researches primary sources, including old cookbooks, church booklets, and period advertisements, before adapting a recipe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>