Recipe Rewind - Vintage Recipes Worth Remembering

• About Recipe Rewind   • Shop Vintage Inspired  

  • Main Course
    • Beef Recipes
    • Breakfast Recipes
    • Casserole Recipes
    • Lunch
    • Pasta Recipes
    • Poultry Recipes
    • Soups + Stews
  • Sides + More
    • Appetizers
    • Drinks + Cocktails
    • Potato Recipes
    • Salads
    • Sandwiches
    • Side Dishes
    • Snacks
    • Vegetable Recipes
  • Bread Recipes
    • Yeast Bread Recipes
    • Quick Bread Recipes
  • Sweet Treats
    • Cakes + Cupcakes
    • Cookies
    • Confections & Sweet Treats
    • Pie Recipes
  • Holidays
    • Fall + Halloween
    • Thanksgiving
    • Winter + Christmas
    • Cinco de Mayo
    • Mother's Day Recipes
    • Summer Holiday Recipes
  • Kitchen Tips

Vintage Thanksgiving Recipes: Made From Scratch Since 1863

Vintage Thanksgiving recipes on Recipe Rewind trace back to the 1621 Plymouth harvest feast, Sarah Josepha Hale's decades-long campaign that made Thanksgiving a national holiday in 1863, and the mid-20th-century inventions that shaped the modern table, including canned cranberry sauce and green bean casserole. We've tested every recipe in a modern kitchen while staying true to the flavors that built this holiday.


Scroll to Explore

Vintage Thanksgiving Recipes: The Dishes Behind a 400-Year-Old Holiday

Vintage Thanksgiving recipes come from a holiday that took over two centuries to become official. A magazine editor spent decades lobbying five presidents before Abraham Lincoln finally declared a national Thanksgiving Day in 1863, in the middle of the Civil War.

Everything most families now consider essential, canned cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, even the modern date on the calendar, arrived far later than the holiday itself. Every recipe below has been tested in a modern kitchen while staying true to the flavors that shaped this table.

We've tested each recipe below in a modern kitchen while staying true to the dishes that built this table over four centuries: roasted turkey, savory stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy, cranberry sauce, and the pies that closed out the meal. These are the recipes worth understanding before you cook them, not just the ones worth eating.

November 17, 2026

Sweet Potato Custard: The 1870 Dessert Used in a Cannery Poisoning


Sweet Potato Custard: The 1870 Dessert Used in a Cannery Poisoning

July 4, 2026

Libby’s Pumpkin Pie Recipe: The 1951 “Pilgrim Pie” Secret Step Most Bakers Skip


Libby’s Pumpkin Pie Recipe: The 1951 “Pilgrim Pie” Secret Step Most Bakers Skip

November 14, 2025

1930 Candied Cranberries Recipe: Sugar-Frosted Jewels for Your Holiday Table


1930 Candied Cranberries Recipe: Sugar-Frosted Jewels for Your Holiday Table

November 11, 2025

1949 Baked Acorn Squash, Steamed Under Foil and Glazed With Molasses


1949 Baked Acorn Squash, Steamed Under Foil and Glazed With Molasses

November 6, 2025

Mrs. Richmond’s Prize-Winning 1931 Pecan Pie Recipe, Built on Karo and Folded Egg Whites


Mrs. Richmond’s Prize-Winning 1931 Pecan Pie Recipe, Built on Karo and Folded Egg Whites

November 5, 2025

Chestnut Sausage Stuffing: A 1960s Thanksgiving Classic


Chestnut Sausage Stuffing: A 1960s Thanksgiving Classic

November 5, 2025

The Creamed Pearl Onions Recipe Depression-Era Cooks Built on a Can of Evaporated Milk


The Creamed Pearl Onions Recipe Depression-Era Cooks Built on a Can of Evaporated Milk

November 4, 2025

Old Fashioned 3 Ingredient Cranberry Sauce from 1903, Simple and Versatile


Old Fashioned 3 Ingredient Cranberry Sauce from 1903, Simple and Versatile

November 2, 2025

Vintage 1965 Apple Cider Punch Bowl Recipe


Vintage 1965 Apple Cider Punch Bowl Recipe

October 31, 2025

Apple Cider Sweet Potato Bread Recipe: 3 Warm Spiced Holiday Loaves


Apple Cider Sweet Potato Bread Recipe: 3 Warm Spiced Holiday Loaves

October 30, 2025

1995 Make Ahead Cream Cheese Potato Soufflé


1995 Make Ahead Cream Cheese Potato Soufflé

October 30, 2025

Turkey Giblet Gravy Recipe From a 1901 Buffalo Newspaper, Made the 1970s Way


Turkey Giblet Gravy Recipe From a 1901 Buffalo Newspaper, Made the 1970s Way

Page [tcb_pagination_current_page] of [tcb_pagination_total_pages]

First

Previous

Next

Last

The History Behind Thanksgiving

The First Thanksgiving Was a Harvest Feast

In the autumn of 1621, Plymouth colonists and Wampanoag guests shared a multi-day harvest gathering that would later become known as the "first Thanksgiving." It wasn't an annual tradition at the time, and it wasn't called Thanksgiving by the people who attended it. The version of the story most Americans learn didn't get widely popularized until centuries later, largely through 19th-century writing that romanticized the event.

One Magazine Editor Spent Decades Fighting for a National Holiday

Sarah Josepha Hale, editor of Godey's Lady's Book, campaigned for a national Thanksgiving holiday for close to two decades before it happened. She petitioned five different presidents, and none of them acted until she wrote directly to Abraham Lincoln in September 1863, arguing Thanksgiving needed "national recognition and authoritative fixation" to become a true American institution.

Lincoln Made It Official in the Middle of a Civil War

Less than a week after receiving Hale's letter, Lincoln issued a proclamation on October 3, 1863, declaring the last Thursday of November a national Thanksgiving Day. He did it while the country was still at war with itself, just months after Gettysburg, framing the holiday as an appeal for unity rather than a celebration of abundance.

FDR Tried to Move the Date, and America Pushed Back

In 1939, President Franklin Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week to extend the Christmas shopping season, a decision so unpopular it earned the nickname "Franksgiving." Congress settled the fight for good in 1941, fixing Thanksgiving permanently as the fourth Thursday in November, the same date we still use.

Canned Cranberry Sauce and Green Bean Casserole Are More Modern Than You Think

Marcus Urann started selling the first commercial cranberry sauce in 1912, though it didn't reach national shelves until 1941 under the cooperative that eventually became Ocean Spray. Green bean casserole came along even later, invented in 1955 by Campbell's home economist Dorcas Reilly, who built it around canned green beans and a can of cream of mushroom soup so home cooks could use pantry staples most of them already had.

Home to Thanksgiving, 1867

A Kitchen & Culture Timeline

1621

Plymouth colonists and Wampanoag guests share a multi-day harvest feast later remembered as the "first Thanksgiving."

1817

New York becomes one of the first states to formally adopt an annual Thanksgiving holiday, well ahead of national recognition.

1863

President Lincoln declares the last Thursday of November a national Thanksgiving Day, days after receiving Sarah Josepha Hale's letter.

1912

Marcus Urann sells the first commercial cranberry sauce, though it stays a regional Massachusetts product for decades.

1939

FDR's "Franksgiving" date change sparks public backlash; Congress fixes Thanksgiving permanently as the fourth Thursday in November.

1941

Canned cranberry sauce reaches national shelves for the first time, under the cooperative that becomes Ocean Spray.

1953

Swanson turns 260 tons of surplus Thanksgiving turkey into the first mass-marketed TV dinner.

1955

Campbell's home economist Dorcas Reilly invents green bean casserole using canned beans and condensed soup.

What Thanksgiving Looked Like Before the Modern Table

Portrait of Sarah Hale

It Took Almost Twenty Years to Make This Holiday Official

Sarah Josepha Hale wasn't a politician or a general. She ran a women's magazine and used it as her platform, writing editorials and letters for nearly two decades urging the country to fix Thanksgiving on a single national date. Four presidents before Lincoln ignored her.

Lincoln didn't. Her September 1863 letter reached him less than three months after Gettysburg, and his proclamation five days later leaned on unity and gratitude in the middle of the Civil War, not abundance at the table. Thanksgiving's origin is closer to a wartime appeal than a harvest celebration.

Frozen TV dinner

Turkey Surplus Accidentally Invented the TV Dinner

In 1953, Swanson badly overestimated how much turkey Americans would eat for the holiday and ended up with 260 tons of frozen bird sitting in ten refrigerated rail cars with nowhere to go. Rather than eat the loss, the company packaged the surplus turkey into individual trays with peas and mashed potatoes.

They called it the TV dinner, and it became one of the most recognizable products of the decade. A holiday built on gratitude for a good harvest accidentally launched an entirely new category of American convenience food.

Green Bean Casserole Wasn't Even a Holiday Recipe at First

When an Associated Press reporter called Campbell's in 1955 asking for a simple vegetable side using pantry staples, home economist Dorcas Reilly built one from canned green beans, canned cream of mushroom soup, and fried onions. She called it "green bean bake," and the AP printed it with no holiday attached at all.

Campbell's didn't rename it "green bean casserole" and start marketing it as a Thanksgiving dish until the 1960s, printed directly on the soup can label. A recipe built for any Tuesday dinner became one of the most requested dishes at the holiday table almost by accident.

Recipe Rewind - Vintage Recipes Worth Remembering

Copyright 2026 Recipe Rewind - Privacy Policy

>
Home to Thanksgiving, 1867