This vanilla wafer recipe is adapted from a 1958 Good Housekeeping cookie collection, using the classic roll-and-slice icebox method with real butter and vanilla extract. The dough forms into logs, chills, and slices into uniform rounds, a technique that produces crispy homemade vanilla wafers with tender centers, ready for banana pudding or snacking.
Remember sneaking vanilla wafers from the box before they made it into banana pudding, the way they'd stick to the roof of your mouth?
This vanilla wafer recipe traces back to a 1958 Good Housekeeping cookie collection, where the roll-and-slice icebox method turned real butter, sugar, and vanilla extract into crispy, uniform cookies without a single drop cookie in sight.
I've been making these vanilla wafers from scratch for years, and here's what keeps me coming back: you taste actual vanilla and butter, not synthetic vanilla flavoring.
These wafers bake up crisp around the edges with centers that stay tender enough to melt on your tongue. They're sturdy enough for banana pudding but delicate enough to enjoy with afternoon tea. You'll get about seven dozen cookies from one batch, which means you can fill your cookie jar and still have plenty for gifting.
Back in 1958, When Good Housekeeping Set the Rules for Home Baking
In 1958, Good Housekeeping had already spent seven decades building its reputation as the household authority American women trusted, and its cookie collections carried real weight in kitchens across the country.

That year, Elvis Presley was sworn into the Army, hula hoops became a national craze after Wham-O sold 25 million of them over one summer, and NASA was created when President Eisenhower signed the National Aeronautics and Space Act into law.
The average household income sat around 4,650 dollars a year, and a three-bedroom suburban home cost about 12,000 dollars, which meant a reliable icebox cookie recipe that stretched a stick of butter and a handful of pantry staples mattered to home bakers watching every dollar.
Kitchens Ran on the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval
Home cooks in 1958 leaned on Good Housekeeping's tested recipes because the magazine's institute had spent decades vetting products and techniques before they reached a housewife's kitchen table.
A vanilla wafer recipe printed in one of their cookie collections carried an implicit guarantee of reliability, since the magazine's entire brand was built on trust and consistency rather than trends.
Icebox Cookies Solved a Real Weeknight Problem
Roll-and-slice icebox dough let a 1958 home baker prepare a log of dough ahead of time and slice off only what she needed, a technique that fit a household economy still recovering from wartime rationing habits and stretching ingredients across multiple bakes.
This made-ahead convenience mattered in kitchens where women often managed baking around other household duties without modern conveniences like reliable refrigeration timing charts.

1958 Good Housekeeping Vanilla Wafer Recipe
This vanilla wafer recipe comes straight from a 1958 Good Housekeeping cookie collection, using the classic roll-and-slice icebox method with real butter and vanilla extract. The chilled dough slices into uniform rounds that bake up crispy at the edges with a tender center, perfect for banana pudding or gifting in a tin.
- Total Time: 3 Hours 25 Minutes
- Yield: 7 Dozen 1x
Ingredients
- 3 cups sifted all-purpose flour
- 3 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 2 large eggs, unbeaten
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
Instructions
- Sift dry ingredients: Measure flour, baking powder, and salt into a sifter. Sift together into a medium bowl and set aside.
- Cream butter and sugar: In a medium-sized mixing bowl, cream butter (or margarine) until soft and smooth. Add sugar gradually, creaming after each addition until the mixture is light and fluffy, about 3-4 minutes.
- Add eggs and vanilla: Beat in eggs and vanilla extract until completely combined and mixture looks smooth.
- Combine wet and dry: Add the sifted dry ingredients to the creamed mixture and blend well until no dry flour streaks remain. Do not overmix.
- Shape and chill dough: Divide dough in half. Shape each half into a roll about 2 inches in diameter. Wrap each roll tightly in waxed paper or plastic wrap. Chill in refrigerator until firm, about 3 hours.
- Bring oven to temp: Preheat oven to 400°F.
- Slice dough: Place chilled rolls on a cutting board covered with waxed paper. Using a sharp knife, cut dough into â…›-inch thick slices. Place slices on ungreased cookie sheets, spacing them about 1 inch apart.
- Bake: Bake in preheated 400°F oven for about 10 minutes, or until edges are lightly golden brown. Watch carefully during the last few minutes to prevent burning.
- Cool: Remove from oven and let cool on baking sheets for 2-3 minutes, then transfer to wire racks to cool completely.
Pin This Homemade Vanilla Wafers Recipe For Later

What Makes These the Best Homemade Vanilla Wafers
Store-bought vanilla wafers can't compete with this recipe, and here's exactly why that's true.
Real Vanilla Extract Does the Heavy Lifting
Most modern cookie recipes call for one teaspoon of vanilla extract. This recipe calls for one tablespoon, which is three times as much, and you'll taste every drop. Pure vanilla extract🛒blooms into the butter mixture and carries through the entire bake. Using imitation vanilla flavoring here would be a legitimate waste of your afternoon. Splurge on a good bottle.
Unsalted Butter at the Right Temperature
Softened butter is the foundation of good cookie dough, but "softened" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. Your butter should be cool room temperature, meaning it holds its shape but gives when you press it. If it looks shiny or greasy, it's too warm and your cookies will spread flat. Pull it out of the fridge about 30 to 45 minutes before you start and let it come up gradually.
Chilled Dough Is Not Optional
The chilled dough step is the one people skip when they're in a hurry, and it's also the step that makes the difference between a wafer with crispy edges and a cookie that spreads into a sad puddle. Wrapping your cookie dough logs tightly in plastic wrap and resting them for a full three hours firms up the butter and hydrates the dry ingredients evenly. You can even leave the logs in the fridge overnight if that's more convenient.
All-Purpose Flour, Sifted
Sifting your all-purpose flour before measuring it isn't just a vintage habit; it removes lumps and ensures your flour mixture incorporates smoothly without overworking the dough. Spoon the sifted flour into your measuring cup and level it off rather than scooping directly from the bag, which compacts the flour and throws off the ratio.
The Roll-and-Slice Method
This technique is what separates these from a drop cookie recipe. Shaping the dough into logs produces equal-sized cookies with consistent thickness, which means they bake evenly across the entire prepared baking sheet. No burnt edges while the centers are still raw. No guessing whether they're done because some are thick and some are thin.
How to Make Perfect Homemade Vanilla Wafers
Homemade vanilla wafers come out perfectly crisp when you control three things: butter temperature, dough thickness, and oven watch time. Here's how to handle each one.
Get Your Butter Temperature Right
Before anything else, check that your unsalted butter is softened but not melted or greasy. In the bowl of a stand mixer 🛒 fitted with the paddle attachment (or using handheld beaters 🛒 in a large mixing bowl), cream the butter on medium speed until it's smooth and slightly fluffy.
Add your sugar gradually and keep going for three to four minutes. You're looking for a butter mixture that looks pale, almost ivory, and feels light when you scrape down the sides of the bowl.
Combining the Dry Ingredients
Sift 🛒your all-purpose flour, baking powder, and salt together into a medium bowl. Adding the flour mixture to your butter mixture in two additions rather than dumping it all in at once keeps the cookie dough smooth and prevents the flour from puffing up over the sides of the bowl.
Mix on low speed just until no dry flour streaks remain. Overmixing at this stage develops gluten and makes your wafers tough instead of tender.
Shaping and Wrapping the Logs
Divide the cookie dough into two equal portions. Roll each portion on a lightly floured surface into a log about two inches in diameter and eight to ten inches long. Wrap each log tightly in plastic wrap, smoothing out any air pockets as you go.
A zip-top bag over the wrapped log gives extra insurance against the dough drying out in the fridge. Chill for a minimum of three hours, or up to three days.
Slicing Evenly
When you're ready to bake, set each log on a cutting board and use a sharp knife to slice the chilled dough into rounds that are about one-eighth of an inch thick. Aim for slices roughly the thickness of two stacked quarters.
If you're unsure, measure the first few. Place slices on a parchment paper-lined baking sheet, spacing them about one inch apart. A silicone mat works beautifully here too if you prefer it over parchment paper.
Watching the Oven
Bake at 400°F for about 10 minutes, watching closely after the eight-minute mark. You're looking for edges that are just turning golden brown. The centers will look barely set, which is exactly right. Baked cookies continue to firm up on the pan for two to three minutes after they come out of the oven, so don't wait for them to look fully crisp before pulling them. They'll get there on their own.
Cooling Completely Before Storing
Transfer your baked cookies to a wire rack 🛒 and let them cool completely before storing. If you layer warm cookies into an airtight container, the trapped steam will soften them faster than you'd like. Give them at least an hour. They're worth waiting for.
Recipe Variations, Serving Ideas, & Storage
Recipe Variations
Tools & Ingredients Worth Having For This Homemade Vanilla Wafers Recipe
Last update on 2026-11-19 at 15:34 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Creators API
Frequently Asked Questions
Homemade vanilla wafers are one of the best make-ahead cookies in a vintage baker's toolkit. Shape your cookie dough into logs, wrap them tightly in plastic wrap, and refrigerate for up to three days before slicing and baking. If you need even more lead time, the wrapped logs freeze well for up to three months. Bake them fresh within a day or two of serving for the best crispy texture.
Flat, spread-out wafers almost always come down to butter that was too warm when you creamed it, or chilled dough that didn't get enough time in the fridge. Softened butter should hold its shape and feel cool to the touch, not look glossy or greasy. Make sure the chilled dough rests for the full three hours before slicing, which firms up the fat and keeps each cookie from collapsing when it hits a hot oven.
I would not use margarine. Butter produces far superior flavor and texture. Margarine has more water content and will create cookies that spread more and have less flavor. If you must use margarine, choose stick margarine (not tub or whipped) with at least 80% fat content.
Aim for â…›-inch thickness, which is about the thickness of two stacked quarters. Thinner slices will burn before the centers set. Thicker slices won't develop crispy edges and will taste more like soft sugar cookies. Use a ruler the first time to calibrate your eye.
This 1950s recipe uses real butter and real vanilla extract, which creates authentic vanilla flavor you can actually taste. Modern commercial vanilla wafers switched to synthetic vanillin in the 1990s, which is why store-bought versions taste different from what you might remember from childhood. This recipe also uses a roll-and-slice method instead of drop cookies, ensuring uniform size.
Vanilla wafer dough can be frozen. Shape the dough into logs, wrap tightly in plastic wrap and then aluminum foil, and freeze for up to 3 months. You can slice and bake directly from frozen (add 1-2 minutes to baking time), or thaw overnight in the refrigerator before slicing for easier cutting.
You need real vanilla extract, not imitation vanilla flavoring. The recipe calls for one tablespoon, which is more than most modern recipes. Don't reduce it. Also, make sure your baking powder is fresh (less than 6 months old). Old baking powder contributes a metallic taste that masks the vanilla.
This vanilla wafer recipe stays crispiest in an airtight container at room temperature, away from direct sunlight or heat, for up to 5 days. Never store them in the refrigerator, as the humid, cold environment causes moisture loss that actually makes crisp cookies go stale faster rather than staying fresh.
Yes, but I recommend waiting at least 2 hours after baking for them to fully crisp up and cool completely. Warm cookies will make your pudding layer watery. These homemade vanilla wafers hold up better in banana pudding than store-bought versions because they're thicker and sturdier.
Roll each half of the dough into a log about 2 inches in diameter and roughly 8-10 inches long. This diameter produces cookies that are similar in size to commercial vanilla wafers. Larger diameter rolls create cookies that won't fit properly in standard banana pudding dishes.
The Cookie That Earns Its Place in the Recipe Box
Some recipes you make once to say you did. These homemade vanilla wafers are the ones you'll keep coming back to, because the chilled dough logs in your fridge mean a fresh batch is never more than 13 to 15 minutes away from the oven.
They're crispy enough to hold up in banana pudding, delicate enough to disappear off a plate in under five minutes, and simple enough that you won't dread making them on a weeknight.
The box version had its moment. Yours is better.
Did you grow up sneaking vanilla wafers straight from the package, or were they always layered into something bigger at your house? Drop a comment and tell me about it. And if you make this recipe, a quick rating goes a long way toward helping other home bakers find it.
If you love a good cookie jar staple, don't stop here! Our 1968 Ginger Snaps recipe brings the same nostalgic, from-scratch spirit with a spicier, molasses-forward bite.


